Wednesday, 5 March 2014

"On the beach" about the realness of Frank Hurley's images

Frank Hurley is my one of my favorite photographers. He was well known for going the extra mile to 'get the shot' in horrendous and sometimes life-threatening situations. Any arduous and dedicated photographer, especially one who delivers technically and aesthetically strong images, should be an inspiration to all developing photographers. I'm not alone in my admiration of Hurley.

Hurley on the deck of the Endurance with his huge camera. Imaging carrying that thing around.
http://www.paulillsley.com/shackleton/03.jpg
 
His images are iconic, and many credit his photographs as the main reason Shackleton's Endurance Expedition is so well known. For good reason. Sure, we can all envision a scene where their ship is being crushed in the ice, but actually seeing visual evidence of this really brings home what they went through:

Endurance beset in ice
http://quitecontinental.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/endurance.jpg


The sad remnants of Endurance
http://www.slate.com/content/dam/slate/blogs/behold/2012/10/11/Shackleton/Shackleton6_Hurley.jpg

In our class discussions about 'real' photography, Hurley was mentioned as someone who, it was  revealed in 2004, 'faked' some of his photos. This does raise some important questions: Does this change how we understand the predicament that Shackleton and his men went through? Are these photographs no longer 'real'? Should this revelation change the way we (or I) feel about Hurley as an inspiration?

Hurley's motto was "Near enough is not good enough". I am inspired every time I read this phrase, and in my growth as a photographer, I use this motto as motivation to go the extra mile. As I evaluate my position about Hurley, I can say that my opinion of him is not diminished. Perhaps I will be more careful about how I interpret his work, but we all, to some extent, and correct me if I am wrong, have a level of comfort with digital manipulation of our own images. Knowing this, we should probably be careful with how we interpret everyone's work.

Are my own photographs 'real'? I'm not comfortable compositing images of my own, but I've removed lampposts from otherwise beautiful images to attain the scene that I want, and I've sold these images without saying so. I routinely retouch and crop my image for a better effect. I guess this puts me firmly "on the beach" between real and unreal images, between being a real and not so real photographer. I'm ok with that. 

How do you feel about Hurley?

1 comment:

  1. I too am a Hurley admirer. A few years ago, I received a book about The Endurance adventure (http://www.amazon.com/Endurance-Caroline-Alexander/dp/1565114183) for Christmas, and was absolutely blown away. The types of images that Hurley was able to capture were simply astounding, as I completely agree that these photographs help provide the reader with some perspective of how grueling the conditions actually were for those long, and cold 20-months. While the news that some of his images were actually composites certainly comes as a surprise, for me, it does not take anything away from this man's technical prowess, and steadfast determination. That being said, the question of whether or not these photographs can now be considered "real" remains up for debate. According to Peter Eastway's article that we read last night, he can be seen to suggest that photos are never real, due to the fact that photographers are the ones who are in charge of framing the scene, choosing what, and what not to include. However, Eastway goes on to say that "photography is a language which can be used in different ways," as perhaps disagreeing as to what is a real, or not real photograph is a fairly arbitrary conversation. Continuing with this photography as a language analogy, I wonder why the photographic world is so caught up on putting a firm definition on the reality of an image? If we can agree that photography is an art form, I would argue that the photographer should be free to portray his/her image however they see fit, composited or not. With this, I applaud Hurley's efforts for creatively portraying aspects of the crew's experience, and will continue to look back on some of his photos for inspiration.

    ReplyDelete