Thursday, 6 March 2014

The Dichotomy Between Art and Photography – Where do we draw the line?

The work of Erik Johansson has long caught my attention, carving out a niche as cutting-edge, surreal images that have been retouched to depict fairy-tale like scenes. After reading Peter Eastways’ blog post debating the issue of what constitutes real photography or not, Johansson’s work is clearly on the ‘artistic’ end of the spectrum. Here are some of his pieces:




One thing that Johansson brands himself on is that his images would be ‘impossible’ to capture otherwise. His profile states that he uses photography as a means to “capture ideas”, and that photography “is just a way to collect material to realize my ideas” in his mind.
Take for instance Johansson’s ‘Drifting Away’ piece, featuring the bottle floating in water containing a surreal world of farm houses and a church (seen below). Although it was composed of original images, over one hundred different photoshop layers and retouches were done to this piece. Could this constitute a photograph? Eastway would think not, and I’d have to agree, it should be defined more generally as ‘art’, despite Johansson’s label for himself as a photographer.



That being said, images like Johansson’s and other retouched images raise an interesting dichotomy within the realm of photography. On one hand, photography attempts to capture reality as accurately as possible. On the other, photography is in many ways another form of art – subject to the photographers bias as well as their chosen artistic manipulations. Perhaps photography needs to distinguish between reality and artistic expression more clearly.

I personally draw the line between photography and other forms of artistic expression when the meaning of the original image or idea is altered. For example, if one were to photoshop a baby sitting on top of a dog. The original photo was simply of a dog; whereas adding a child on top is altering the original meaning of the image. 

In contrast, despite the heavily retouched nature of Johansson’s work, he utilizes photography as a tool to better realize his imagination and surreal scenes. In this sense, the original meaning of his photographs and ideas are still maintained, despite the effects applied. They aren't meant to convey reality, they're meant to convey imaginary and surreal worlds.


Regardless of what others may think of this debate, Johansson’s work is an incredible collection of art blended by vivid imagination and skill.

No comments:

Post a Comment