Sunday, 16 March 2014

Take a walk with Bruce Gilden

Fresh off our last trip to Vancouver, I still have street photography on my mind.  There is something about it that makes me excited, nervous, and uncomfortable all at the same time, and I think that is fantastic.  While doing research for our presentation on photography and ethics on Tuesday, I ran into this great clip of street photographer Bruce Gilden.  If you have the time, you should take a look.  It's only about 4 minutes long.


After my first time through the video, I thought it was just some random segment from another arrogant, and pushy New Yorker.  The way he went about taking photos seemed disrespectful, and invasive.  Surely, it was not the technique that I employed while on the streets of Vancouver last Friday.  However, as he mentions in the video, he has been taking photos in Manhattan since 1981, so he must have some knowledge within this field.  Upon doing a bit more research on this bizarre man, I was humbly put in my place.  It turns out that Bruce Gilden is one of the more prominent street photographers working today.  Though perhaps unorthodox in his methods from our beginner's perspective, there is no denying that he has had success in honing his craft.

Throughout the video, there are a few things Bruce said that caught my attention.  First of all, he seems to give a few tips for aspiring street photographers, noting, "if you can smell the street in the photo, then it's a street photograph."  As you can tell from the video clip, Bruce is not afraid to get up close and personal with his subjects.  That is part of who he is, part of his character, and I think that personality plays to his strengths in his work.  Further, he talks about how he likes to use flash to "help visualize my feelings about the city" while out on the town.  Though I never thought about using my flash while we were in Vancouver, I do think it has the potential to add to some images you capture, and perhaps make your intentions more deliberate.  Finally, perhaps the most shocking thing Mr. Gilden said in his video was that he "has no ethics."  Calling the streets of New York a "war zone," it seems to me Gilden is suggesting he has no ruling guidelines in trying to capture the photo he wants.  To state this so blatantly certainly caught me off guard, but the more I think about it, the closer I come to seeing Bruce's point.  One argument in the ethics of photography is that they are ultimately subjective, as this is something we will expand upon during our presentation on Tuesday.  However, in the meantime, I would be curious to hear your own reactions to Bruce's video, his photographic work, and if you have any comments on his disregard for ethics while photographing.

Cheers,

Jordi



9 comments:

  1. Yikes. I would not like to run into Bruce on the street. I'm simultaneously impressed and a little disturbed. He's so aggressive! The way he jumped in front of that old woman 30 seconds in or so......I'm just not sure I approve of all his methods. That said, he does take some fantastic photographs. He says he has no ethics and that's very clear to me based on his behavior but the idea that the streets are a war zone has me especially concerned. Do we all just agree to this by walking on public sidewalks? I don't think so. I think his actions border on harassment. I also noticed that in the video he tends to take photos of women and generally people who are older, shorter/smaller than him, non-threatening. At 3:12 there's a BIG guy wearing a Mets jersey right in front of him and he sort of brings his camera up, finger at the ready for a photograph, but hesitates and pulls back. I wonder if he's pretty selective with who he photographs for fear of consequences in his supposed "war zone." In that sense I might call him somewhat of an untruthful photographer as his street photography is not representative. Thoughts? (I haven't looked at his larger body of work but am just basing this on the video...)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I would definitely agree that Bruce is controversial in his methods. That being said, I was surprised to see the general lack of response he received after he would jump out at his subjects. I would have expected much more of a reaction, especially in a city like New York, but perhaps Bruce had a point in saying that the people who walk the streets are so wrapped up in their own little worlds, that they just don't care. Though I did not try it myself, I am sure that I would have received more than an earful if I tried a similar approach with my street photography assignment last Friday in Vancouver.. With regards to Bruce being a selective photographer, I do not know if we can make such a claim based on the people he happened to shoot during a five minute clip. I see your point though, that the people he chose to photograph were relatively non-imposing. However, if you check out the link to his website that was provided in the first post, I think you will get a better idea of the diversity in his work. Further, after being in the business for over thirty years, I do not think Bruce Gilden is the type of person that shies away from any photographs because his subject matter may seem intimidating. After all, he has established himself as a street photographer in New York city, one of the more "rough and tumble" places in the United States, so I imagine that he has developed some pretty thick skin over the years. In that sense, I would respectively disagree and call Bruce a truthful photographer because he stays true to himself and takes photos of subjects that he finds interesting. Within any field of photography, I don't know if you can capture anything that is completely "representative" of the environment as a whole because the photographer will always be under the influence of his or her own unintentional bias. Food for thought?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Talk about getting in there!
    This is an awesome video Jordi, and inspires me to do the same my next time around in the city for portraiture shots. It is remarkable how people just go about not confronting Bruce the way I would assume a person would if a your were to take a flash photo of a subject. Although, there were people who did comment a few times in the video, Bruce was pretty slick and made the situation somewhat comfortable with what he would say to them. Bruce goes right into his subject without hesitation, and I this is KEY if you want to do something of this sort. I think if you were to hesitate, it gives your subject a bit more time to respond to what is going to happen, thus creating an awkward situation. Bruce is a point and shoot kind of guy, and the images he gets from that is priceless.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hmm, I'm not sure I would agree that Gilden is a truthful photographer. He certainly captures some striking images and manages to portray emotion in his shots. However, I found it interesting how he tends to censor peoples reactions. When the two old men responded to having the camera pointed in their faces by smiling, he told them to stop smiling and just keep walking. Later in the video he commented on a photo he took of a woman smiling, saying it was awful because she had smiled. He seems to want a certain reaction from people, anger or surprise perhaps... Or maybe he wants no reaction at all. But I can't say he is necessarily truthful in portraying the subjects when he refuses to let them react in a way that is natural for them. Doesn't the compulsive need to smile at a camera also say something interesting about a person or about our culture?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think it's strange when we separate people's unethical actions from their photographs. Throughout our discussions many have made comments about the circumstances of the shot being morally questionable but the shot being aesthetically pleasing and therefore being accepted. Although Gilden's moral faults (i.e. shamelessly invading people's personal spaces) pale in comparison to taking a picture of a dead child, the comments about his work reveal something about out way of thinking. I think that too often we put entertainment before what is right. Photographers like Gilden, Gallea and the photographers who took pictures of that dead girl in Haiti, cross the line and take pictures like that because people want to see them. These professional photographers would probably stop taking such pictures if there was a lack of interest, if us viewers demanded respect for the subjects. I wonder what street photography, or in a more general sense, photographs on a whole would look like if viewers were more vocal.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'd have to side with Oscar on this one and agree that Gilden isn't an unethical photographer. Maybe he isn't respectful of his subjects, but, what he is doing is completely legal. If his subjects were indeed annoyed with him they could have easily asked him to delete the photograph. Also, maybe the fact that he is so confident in himself and his photographic abilities contributes to his success. In my experience, I've found that if I'm timid when taking photographs or asking to take photographs, people often judge the intentions of what they will be used for. Who is going to trust a 20-something looking student with a camera anyways that seems unsure of himself taking photographs of people? Gildens approach on the other hand is very involved, and, his confidence, arrogance, and invasion of privacy (as well as appearance of being somewhat of a professional with the flash), may give people the impression that he is an accomplished photographer without any harmful intentions. Perhaps if he becomes famous enough, Gilden's approach and style may become the new norm of street photography, and his subjects might become more accustomed to his approach.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow, this guys has some moves! What a crazy video, and a window into how Bruce works as an artist. Great find, Jordi! I think it takes guts to do what he does, getting right up in people's faces like that, but it also takes skill, timing, and he can also be a pretty smooth talker for someone who makes a living jumping out at people on the streets of New York city. It's abrasive, intrusive, and admittedly controversial, but it's also effective, unique and entertaining to watch! Not sure if I'd want to be the one he's jumping out at, but I can't help but give Bruce a nod for doing what he does without regrets.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'd probably wanna punch this guy in the face, but at least he'd be close enough to do so. The contrast between this and somebody in a high rise or across the street in a car with a long lens is striking. I appreciate his in the face style, but the attitude is too New York for me to handle.

    I suppose only in anonymity would this style of shooting work...

    ReplyDelete