Monday, 17 March 2014

The Truth in Illustration Photography

Collaborations can be a hit or miss. Something are just not meant to be together while others are destined to cross paths. One unlikely pair that have found their way to each other is photography and illustration. The mix breaks through the boundaries of reality and creativity by depicting a world that is both within and outside of our own.
Photo by Guilia Pex

When contemplating illustrated photography my mind goes to our discussions about truth. Photos with drawings on them are obviously manipulated; their changes are way more apparent than anything edited in Lightroom or Photoshop. Despite this, I see truth in these kind of pictures. 
When I research the definition of the word 'truth' I see phrases and words like: "in accordance with fact or reality"; "genuine"; "honest". Illustrated photography meets all of the criteria. 
  1. It is a fact that there are drawn images inserted in the photographs.
  2. Illustrated photographs are set in reality with real subjects or settings within the shot.
  3. This type of art form is both genuine and honest in how obviously the images are manipulated. The photographer's intention is to fool the viewer into believing something false but to open the viewer's imagination.

Now I know that it may seem like I'm manipulating the definition of truth but it still makes sense. For me, truth in photography is mostly about intention and honesty. If a photographer takes a photo with the intent of displaying her creativity and is honest about her manipulation of her work, then her photographs are true.


                                                        Photos by Alana Dee Haynes

Click the artists' names to check out their work 



4 comments:

  1. This is an interesting art form that I haven't come across before. On these photographs fitting the definition of truth...I'm not sure I agree that they're in accordance with reality, but I do see what you're saying as far as being true in a certain sense. Again, truth in photography is not black and white but can perhaps be thought of as a spectrum; for example, I see that the illustrated photograph by Pex is clearly illustrated, but the Dee Haynes photos (especially the one on the right) could be misconstrued as tattoos. In this way, and following your interpretation, Pex's illustrated photo may be "truer" than the others.

    ReplyDelete
  2. These are intriguing pieces of art - I've never seen anything quite like it before, especially the photo on the bottom left. It's incredibly abstract, and I think that there is something to be said for integrating the two mediums. As a viewer, I almost expect that the image will either be just a photo or just a drawing, simply due to the fact that it's something that one can come to expect. Something is either X or Y, not XY. Looking at theses photos really made me question what I was seeing. It made me pay attention. Do they represent the truth? I would agree with Jon and say that they may not be representative of reality, but instead are an expression of it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This post is a similar theme to the one that I wrote about Erik Johansson's retouched photographs, and I think you draw out some interesting points about truth and photography. It's been said to me before, and I still abide by this law, but so long as the intention of the image isn't changed, or the meaning through your process is taking the image as well as manipulating and editing it, the photograph remains truthful. I'd have to agree with Jon, however, in the sense that these photographs are not representations of reality – rather, both artists (including Johannson) intentionally try to manipulate images to capture ideas that photography otherwise wouldn't be able to do. The 'truth' in these images isn't so much in the realness of their content, but in their ability to convey truthful ideas in a genuine way without passing it off as a photograph.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like the use of mixed media that this artist uses. It is awesome that he goes beyond photography and makes a piece of art. After thinking about truth in photography, I think that mixed media is its own art form. I agree with Jon that these images do not need to show truth because they are mixed media does not need to show truth. It is more of a artists representation of what they want to express.

    ReplyDelete